Fay & Garst Brewery – IN 105a

Fay & Garst Brewery opened in 1875 and closed in 1877 it was open for 2 years. Breweries that are only open for a couple of years like this did not have a long time to produce advertising and collectibles so they tend to be more scarce than breweries with more longevity. As a Pre-Prohibition Brewery, any advertising items or collectibles are likely to be valuable and desirable to collectors as they tend to be hard to find. Fay & Garst Brewery was located in Muncie, IN, which only had 3 breweries, so there are not many that that were producing breweriana items. Local collectors may pay a small premium over national or general collectors because of a lack of local items.

    For help finding information about or the value of your Breweriana or Old Brewery items, please contact us:

    Breweries listed under Muncie, IN 105

    Brewery IDBrewery NameStart DateEnd Date
    IN 105aFay & Garst Brewery18751877
    IN 105bA. J. Garst Brewery18771882
    IN 105cBartlett & Garst BreweryUnknown1890

    Breweries listed under Muncie, IN

    Brewery IDBrewery NameStart DateEnd Date
    IN 104Ch. Alvery Brewery18781879
    IN 105aFay & Garst Brewery18751877
    IN 106Muncie Brewing Co.19041912